D-Sector for Development Community

   Sunday, May 19, 2013
Agriculture - Duties and Rights - Education - Environment - Food - Global - Governance - Health - Indian Economy - Indian Society - Physical Development - Social Welfare - Water and Sanitation
Print | Back
Lying down for Justice
By S. G. Vombatkere



Hundreds of children are opposing the government plan to acquire lands and forests for the Posco plant. This unique action by children is a warning to the policy makers to reconsider their development strategy before it is too late to make a course correction.


Children lying on the ground to form human rings to stop forced
acquisition of their lands and forests (Photo courtesy: Reuters)

The people and especially the children of Dhinkia, Gadkujang, Govindpur and Nuagaon villages in Jagatsinghpur District in Odisha have shown how people matter over governments' plans for development of business corporations at their cost. The children “illegally” lay down on the hot earth in the blazing summer heat and refused to move to allow entry to government officials to take over forest land and their villages for the POSCO mega-project. This was in the face of around 1,000 policemen armed with lathis, tear gas and rifles threatening dire consequences if the villages were not vacated, making loudspeaker announcements every 15 minutes. Apprehending night or dawn attack by the police, the people have also been maintaining overnight vigils.

This situation prevails not for one or two days but for two weeks, during which normal life in the villages is completely disrupted; the area is essentially in a “state of war”. But the people have been strictly peaceful throughout and have been able to withstand the Odisha government's terror tactics that work towards the strategy of acquiring the land for POSCO in terms of the MoU signed in 2005.

What could be the reason for such strong-arm methods by government and such determined and desperate resistance by the people? The Odisha state government, after clearly violating the Forest Rights Act, and receiving what is essentially an illegal environmental clearance wrongfully accorded by the Union government, is bent upon acquiring land for the POSCO project which it claims is in the “public interest”.

Thus, the people who joined together to block government entry to acquire forest land were declared an unlawful assembly subject to dispersal by use of police force. "Govt officials who are duty bound to acquire forest land here are being prevented. This is unlawful and immoral and so we will do whatever is lawful", said Police Superintendent Devdutt Singh, going so far as to comment on the morality of the resistance. This is topsy-turvy justice and law, implemented by a callous bureaucracy and police under the instruction of corrupt politicians.

The Odisha state government, after clearly violating the Forest Rights Act, and receiving what is essentially an illegal environmental clearance wrongfully accorded by the Union government, is bent upon acquiring land for the POSCO project which it claims is in the “public interest”.

The present situation is a direct result of the environmental clearance accorded by the Union government. This clearance disregards the findings of several independent expert committees appointed by the Union Environment and Forest Minister himself, which recommended that clearances granted must be cancelled as they were obtained by fraud and in violation of various forest rights, forest protection and environmental laws and norms. Now the Minister “hope[s] that the state government will not use this clearance as a license for forcible acquisition of land”, and that the intent and purpose of the clearance was not to allow forcible acquisition of land.

The Minister and all elected and appointed government officials are perhaps under the impression that the heroic children of Dhinkia, Gadkujang, Govindpur and Nuagaon villages are unaware of the organized fraud that governments have committed to give the land to POSCO. It would surprise them to know that all details of the murky deal are known even to 6-year olds, because their future depends upon it. They would not lie in the hot sun and keep vigil at night and face armed police just because their parents required it.

These future citizens of Odisha and India are asking, “Is this what development means – robbing thousands of their lands and livelihoods and threatening lakhs with water shortage and other catastrophes to suit the needs of wealthy corporations?” They are also aware of government's land-grabbing actions elsewhere in Odisha and India.

The writing has been on the wall for many years and was boldly visible in Nandigram. Now the writing is redundant; the action is here. This brave act of the children is not merely a call for justice; it indicates their preparedness for a long struggle against the government, which is now being perceived as their adversary. Can anybody guarantee that today's peaceful resistance by children will remain so, as they grow up in an ambience of intimidation by government?

 
Disclaimer:
The views expressed above are personal and do not necessarily reflect the views of d-sector editorial team.
 

S. G. Vombatkere  |  sg9kere@live.com

Maj Gen S. G. Vombatkere (VSM) (retired) is engaged in voluntary work with Mysore Grahakara Parishat, and is a member of National Alliance of People’s Movements (NAPM) and People’s Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL). Settled in Mysore, he is Adjunct Associate Professor of the University of Iowa, USA.

Write to the Author  |  Write to d-sector  |  Editor's Note
 


 Other Articles by S. G. Vombatkere in
Political Development  > Duties and Rights > Economic and Social Rights

Odisha's little Gandhians
Monday, August 01, 2011

After inspection of the villages peacefully resisting the POSCO project in Odisha, the NCPCR has justified the children's participation in the ongoing agitation terming it 'voluntary'.

Farmers know what they need
Friday, February 26, 2010

As sustained propaganda to establish private laboratory's control over farmers' rights is gathering momentum, a unique Farmers' Jury comprised of small and marginal farmers from diverse communities and regions asserted their right to be consulted for farm research and policy making.
 
 Other Articles in Political Development
 
 
Coke Nation

The news that Indians consume far less aerated beverages each year than their neighbours in Pakistan and China could be interpreted differently. In comparison to per capita annual consumption of 39 and 21 bottles of aerated drinks in China and Pakistan respectively, average Indian drinks just about 14 bottles in a year. For Coca-Cola this means a serious job at hand for which the company has announced an advertisement budget of $5 billion. For the company, economic growth of a country and its peoples' thirst for aerated beverages is directly coorelated. 

Coca-Cola doesn't consider 'negative' publicity for cola behind poor consumption of the aerated beverage in India. As per its books, brand Coca-Cola has registered consecutive growth for past 27 quarters and has been a leader with a brand volume of 30 per cent. For Coca-Cola the target is to turn it into a 'Coke Nation', on the lines of Mexico where per capita annual consumption is 745 bottles..Whether Indian consumer exercises restraint in gulping the drink whose health consequences are all but known, the flipside to the story is that  the state governments are falling prey to Coca-Cola's investment plans?

Waste Appetite

The clock has turned full circle! After dumping industrial and toxic trash in the developing world all these years, Europe is now shopping for garbage to keep its cities, schools and homes heated. What better place than the developing world to shop for garbage! Reports indicate that northern Europe needs more than 700 million tons of trash to keep its waste-to-energy plants running. Most of its current demand is either domestically met or from garbage shipped from southern Europe.Yet, the demand is far more than what neighboring countries can spare after meeting their domestic needs. 

As more waste incinerators are being built in Sweden, Norway, Austria and Germany to meet the growing demand for heating public places, these countries are left with two options - either encourage households to produce more trash or else import garbage from across the world. For sure, it is easy to import than to produce! A company in England is already shipping some 1,000 tons of garbage to keep its systems running. Since incinerators have cornered environmental controversy in India and for rightful reasons, there exists an opportunity to explore feasibility of exporting as much as 109,589 tonnes of garbage that piles our streets on a daily basis. 

Lead View
To pee or not to pee
By Sudhirendar Sharma
21 Apr 2013

Sustained pollution of major rivers; continuous decline in groundwater reserves; priority allocation to non-consumptive sectors; and, growing disparity in water distribution only indicates that the worst is still to come!..
Book Shelf

Water Drops

Provocations for Development

River Dog

Psychology in the Bathroom
Commentators
Devinder Sharma
Carmen Miranda
Pandurang Hegde
Sudhirendar Sharma
Member Login
- New Member
- Forgot Password

Business Plan,Business Ideas,Advanced Energy,High Technology,Healthy Diets,Healthy Foods,Games Guides,Games Cheats,Export Business,US exports,Study Skills,Study Tips,Health Tips,Health Guides,Jewelry Stores,Jewellery UK Online